2009 NMRA Convention - Hartford, Connecticut logo
national train show

Whither goest the NMRA Model Contest?

The NMRA Model Contest has always been inspiring. It is also one of the oldest functions of this organization. Many years ago, the contest was actually administered by Kalmbach in conjunction with the NMRA and this is the forum in which John Allen first came to prominence. He won best structure award back in 1948 for his innovative engine house which featured unheard of realism and something called "weathering". It was a sensation. Since then, the NMRA contest has set the standard for model building. But lately, the NMRA Contest has lost some of its luster in the opinion of many. Some cite the rules which require very careful and almost scientific judging standards. Others cite the application process and the multiple forms which must be filled out successfully and still others claim that there are "tricks" which seasoned contest entrants utilize to gain an advantage over their competitors. Of course, many of these points frankly are urban legend and simply not true, but what is unfortunately true is that over the years the NMRA Convention has slowly diminished in number of entries and some would argue, in overall quality.

Under the innovative leadership of our new Contest Chair Bob Hamm, two new contests will be unveiled in Anaheim to try to bring the fun back to the NMRA Contest. The direct entry People's Choice Awards along with the Model Showcase will allow persons to enter their models for one of three different kinds of evaluation. They can be judged using the NMRA's point system which may qualify the models for achievement program usage. If the model receives 87½ points in the judged contest, it will be qualified for an AP award.

The model can also be entered into the People's Choice Awards where attendees of the Convention will be able to vote for the best model in each category. The model can also be entered in the model showcase which is non-competitive, and simply allows attendees to admire and examine the talented work of their fellow modelers.

Although the NMRA has seen a decline in the number of entries, that is not true in alternative conventions such as the Narrow Gauge Convention or the Prototype Modelers Conventions. Further, we have learned from the popular vote contest at these conventions that the experienced modeler can often be as discerning a judge as the seasoned professional within the NMRA ranks. Thus, the People's Choice Awards present a unique opportunity to test the theory that attendees at NMRA Conventions, themselves experienced modelers, are just as good as the NMRA judges at picking out a winning entry. Whether you choose to enter your model in the NMRA contest, the People's Choice Awards contest or just the Modelers Showcase, you will be participating in a time honored event. Your will be sharing your work with those attending the Convention and inspiring those who view your entry. More importantly, you will be demonstrating that the "model" in National Model Railroad Association does have a significant meaning. Whether for fun - for points - or just because you're proud of your work, I urge you to enter a model in an upcoming NMRA Convention. You'll be glad you did.

Charlie Getz